Review
If you have spent any time in the fantasy corner of the internet over the past couple of years, chances are you are already familiar with the brutal halls of Basgiath War College. Rebecca Yarros's Empyrean series took the reading community by storm, and Threshing Day offers a fascinating, multi-perspective companion piece to that universe. Clocking in at 224 pages, this novella collection zeroes in on one of the most tense and pivotal events in a dragon rider’s training: the deadly trial where cadets stand before dragons to see if they will earn a bond or be turned to ash.Rather than following a single linear narrative, Yarros spreads the spotlight across thirteen distinct figures from the series. Readers get to step into the boots of fan favourites like Xaden Riorson, Rhiannon Matthias, and Liam Mairi, alongside figures like Dain Aetos, Ridoc Gamlyn, Sawyer Henrick, Imogen Cardulo, and even members of the Sorrengail family. Each entry captures the specific moments leading up to and during Threshing Day from that cadet's point of view, interweaving their personal anxieties, rivalries, and interactions with the dragons themselves.
What makes this collection work so well is how quickly it drops you right into the thick of the action. The pacing is remarkably snappy. Because each vignette is relatively brief, there is no fluff or unnecessary narrative padding. You get an immediate hit of tension as each cadet steps onto the treacherous field, fully aware that a single misstep or misplaced bit of arrogance could result in instant incineration.
Yarros's prose remains direct, punchy, and deeply character-driven. It is particularly fun seeing how characters view themselves versus how we originally saw them through Violet’s eyes in Fourth Wing. Dain’s internal monologue, for instance, adds a layer of rigid adherence to duty that feels far more nuanced than his standard portrayal in the main books. Meanwhile, Xaden’s chapter carries that familiar quiet authority, giving us a taste of the immense responsibility he bore even at an earlier stage in his college career.
A major highlight of this deluxe edition is the inclusion of full-colour artwork by Joe Requeza. Having visual representations of the dragons alongside the text gives the trial a rich, tangible weight. The artwork brings out the massive scale and distinct personalities of the dragons, elevating the reading experience beyond a standard tie-in book and making it feel like a genuinely crafted collector’s piece.
That said, the format does bring a few inherent limitations that are worth noting. If you come into Threshing Day expecting a sweeping storyline with massive plot revelations, you might feel a bit let down. It is strictly a companion volume. Some of the vignettes feel far too brief, ending just as you start getting comfortable inside a character's head. Ridoc and Sawyer, for example, are always a treat to spend time with, but their entries leave you wishing for twenty more pages of their sharp banter.
Additionally, because all thirteen stories centre on the exact same afternoon, there is a slight sense of repetition in the fundamental structure. We watch multiple cadets line up in the valley, feel the nervous energy buzzing through the ranks, and wait for dragons to swoop down from the rocks. Readers who aren't deeply invested in the minutiae of Basgiath lore might find the structure a little formulaic by the time they reach the halfway mark.
For me personally, reading Liam's perspective was easily the emotional high point of the book. Knowing his trajectory in the broader series lends a bittersweet weight to his thoughts during Threshing Day. It reminded me why his character resonated so strongly with readers in the first place—his quiet decency and fierce loyalty shine through even in the middle of a cutthroat trial where everyone else is focused on self-preservation.
Who will enjoy this book?
- Hardcore Empyrean fans looking to tide themselves over while waiting for the next main instalment.
- Readers who love character-focused short stories and alternative point-of-view chapters.
- Collectors who appreciate illustrated editions and special formatting (the silver-gilded edges on this hardback look fantastic on display).
- Anyone curious about dragon lore and the specific choices dragons make when selecting their riders.
Threshing Day is not designed to replace the main novels, nor does it pretend to be a standalone epic. Instead, it is a polished, entertaining dip back into a world many of us have come to love. It delivers sharp character glimpses, gorgeous artwork, and plenty of high-stakes dragon drama. If you are already invested in the series, this Deluxe Edition is well worth adding to your bookshelf.
Rating: 4 out of 5 stars.






